a big-picture view of the topic rather than discussing a particular aspect 主题文章而不是某个特定方面
describe how lessons learned from the topic can contribute to new ideas and visions that can stimulate the research community to pursue new directions, e.g., new problems 描述从主题中吸取的经验教训如何有助于产生新的想法和愿景,从而刺激研究界追求新的方向,例如新的问题
a well-defined scope and be understandable for most of the AI community 清晰的、可理解的范围定义
clarify why the topic is important 主题的重要性
and its intended or existing applications 可能的和现存的应用
comprehensive concerning state of the art, with a personal stance on the topic: the description of the existing work should be structured 对最新文章综合全面的陈述,根据作者对该主题的立场,按照结构组织
It should contain a discussion (aiming, for instance, at comparing alternative approaches or identifying open questions and challenges). It should not be a simple juxtaposition of summaries of papers or groups of papers 讨论比较方法和开放问题,而不是简单的罗列
While the authors’ work can sometimes be an important part of a survey, there should be no significant bias towards it: the work of others should be mentioned and appreciated by its relevance and importance 无偏向,讨论现有文章相关性和重要性(赞赏)
very high quality in terms of presentation 表述上非常清晰